Skip to content

New Research Assessment (NRA) Model & Self-assessment

Towards a Practical Framework for Assessing Research Assessment Reform: The First RDA Demonstrator

About this demonstrator

This experimental implementation focuses on individual research assessment reform initiatives, not institutions as a whole. The Frederick University example is entirely fictional and does not represent an actual evaluation of the university.

Research assessment reform is gaining momentum across Europe and internationally. However, an important challenge remains: how can research institutions systematically examine their progress in implementing reform principles, identify areas requiring further attention and make their achievements visible?

Within the RDA project, we are developing an assessment approach intended to address this challenge.

Our longer-term ambition is to support the assessment of research institutions across a range of thematic dimensions of research assessment reform. These may encompass the recognition of diverse research contributions, assessment practices, institutional policies, collaboration, governance and the sustainability of reform efforts.

Rather than proposing a rigid or universally applicable scoring system, we envisage a flexible framework through which institutions can examine their current practices, establish priorities, document achievements and monitor their development over time.

The approach is being progressively developed and tested through a digital environment that supports the organisation of thematic assessment areas, indicators, reference methodologies, supporting evidence and visual representations of progress.

1. A First Experimental Implementation

As a first step, we have deliberately focused on assessing specific research assessment reform initiatives rather than institutions as a whole. Our approach also takes into account the CoARA commitments and the challenges associated with their implementation.

To illustrate these concepts, we have configured a fictional research assessment reform initiative at Frederick University in Cyprus.

This initial implementation demonstrates how the proposed approach can be translated into a practical assessment structure, with thematic indicators, defined assessment criteria and documented achievements.

The example is entirely fictional and does not represent an actual evaluation of Frederick University. Its purpose is to provide a tangible starting point for experimentation, discussion and refinement.

2. From Initiative-Level to Institution-Level Assessment

A broader institutional assessment framework will be explored at a later stage, informed by the evidence, practical experience and stakeholder feedback gathered as the project progresses.

This gradual approach will allow us to test and refine assessment methodologies before considering their application to institutions as a whole.

3. Explore and Contribute

We invite research institutions, researchers and organisations involved in responsible research assessment to explore the demonstrator and contribute their ideas and suggestions.

Your feedback will be particularly valuable in helping us refine the assessment approach, identify relevant thematic dimensions and indicators, and explore how institutional reform progress can best be documented and visualised.

Watch the introductory screencast (opens in a new tab)

Explore the RDA Research Assessment Demonstrator (opens in a new tab)

Questions and feedback

For questions, comments or suggestions, please contact the RDA project team through our Contact page. Please include “RDA demonstrator” in your message so that your enquiry can be directed to the appropriate project contact.

Get involved

Interested in contributing to research assessment reform? Explore RDA’s upcoming consultations, capacity-building activities and participation opportunities.

Get involved

Privacy choices

Read the Cookie Policy