Results & Tools
New Research Assessment (NRA) Model & Self-assessment
A maturity model with four levels.
Four levels
- Level 1Recognition
- Level 2Implementation
- Level 3Institutionalisation
- Level 4Demonstrated Impact
The NRA framework applies a common four-level maturity model to two distinct assessment contexts:
- Reform initiatives: Maturity reflects the progress of a specific initiative, from recognition of the need for reform to demonstrated impact.
- NRA dimensions / stakeholders: Maturity reflects how far reform has progressed within each selected research assessment dimension and stakeholder context.
In both cases, maturity is assessed through appropriate supporting evidence, while institutions retain flexibility in selecting the dimensions relevant to their circumstances. The tables below summarise the approach.
1. Maturity Assessment: Research Assessment Reform Initiatives
| Level | Maturity stage | Description |
|---|---|---|
| M1 | Recognition | Need for reform recognised and a specific initiative identified or proposed. |
| M2 | Implementation | Initiative being implemented in practice, including pilots or initial application. |
| M3 | Institutionalisation | Initiative systematically embedded in routine procedures within its intended scope. |
| M4 | Demonstrated Impact | Evidence of meaningful improvements in research assessment resulting from the initiative. |
2. Maturity Assessment: NRA Dimensions / Stakeholders
| Level | Maturity stage | Description |
|---|---|---|
| M1 | Recognition | Need for change recognised within the selected NRA dimension and stakeholder context. |
| M2 | Implementation | Changes being implemented in assessment practices within the selected dimension and stakeholder context. |
| M3 | Institutionalisation | Changes systematically embedded in routine assessment practices within the selected dimension and stakeholder context. |
| M4 | Demonstrated Impact | Evidence of meaningful improvements in research assessment resulting from changes within the selected dimension and stakeholder context. |
First RDA Research Assessment Demonstrator
RDA is exploring how research assessment reform initiatives can be assessed through thematic indicators, defined assessment criteria and supporting evidence.
The first demonstrator uses a fictional research assessment reform initiative at Frederick University in Cyprus to illustrate the approach and support experimentation, discussion and refinement.
This initial implementation focuses on individual reform initiatives, not institutions as a whole. It does not represent an actual evaluation of Frederick University.
Get involved
Interested in contributing to research assessment reform? Explore RDA’s upcoming consultations, capacity-building activities and participation opportunities.
Get involved